Renewal Mill's CEO on turning food manufacturing byproducts into upcycled food ingredients and pantry products, educating buyers and its partnerships.
About this episode
00:00
Hello, you're watching another episode of the Green New Perspective podcast, a show where we talk about sustainability with guests from the Climate Tech, Nature Tech, and AgriTech space. We dive into the innovations happening within these industries.
My guest today is Caroline Cotto. Caroline is the CEO and co-founder of Renewal Mill, an upcycled food enterprise dedicated to combating climate change and food waste.
If you want to understand why food waste is a critical, often overlooked issue, and how reducing it is one of the most effective strategies to fight climate change, stay with us and listen to what Caroline has to say.
Enjoy.
00:51
Hey Caroline, and welcome to the Green New Perspective podcast.
Thanks so much for having me. Super excited to be here.
Q: Can you explain the significance and impact of food waste and how it connects to climate change?
01:05
Absolutely. Food waste is a massive global problem. We throw away about 40% of the food we produce every year, which is just insane. A lot of that ends up in landfills, where it releases harmful methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
But it's not just the emissions from the waste itself. Wasting food also means wasting all the resources that went into growing it, the water, the nutrients in the soil, the land, and the carbon involved in harvesting and transportation.
According to Project Drawdown, reducing food waste is one of the top strategies we can implement to curb climate warming. It's followed closely by adopting a more plant-based diet. Collectively, food waste contributes to around 8% of total global greenhouse gas emissions. That’s a lot.
Q: Can you talk about Renewal Mill and how you’re helping reduce the impacts of food waste?
02:29
Food waste happens at all points in the supply chain, from the farms, where “ugly” produce is left behind, to homes where people overbuy and underuse groceries. But a significant portion also happens during food manufacturing.
At Renewal Mill, my co-founder and I discovered this issue firsthand. She had a juice company and was left with massive amounts of fruit and vegetable pulp every day. Then, we spoke with the owner of a tofu company who mentioned producing tons of soybean pulp, called okara, every week. It’s a byproduct of tofu production, processed safely and full of fiber and protein.
We realized this nutritious food was being wasted simply because there wasn't a system to use it. That’s how Renewal Mill began, with a mission to “mine” the food system for overlooked nutrition and return it to the human supply chain through upcycling.
Q: The concept of upcycled food is still new to many. How do you educate consumers about its benefits?
04:36
It’s not a new concept, really. If you've ever grown your own food, been a chef, or experienced scarcity, you've probably upcycled. You've done your best to use everything you had.
We help food manufacturers rethink their inputs, what if they could use 100% of what they bring in? Unlike recycling, which breaks down materials, upcycling elevates byproducts into higher uses in their current form.
The formal definition of upcycled food is: something that would otherwise go to waste, that has measurable environmental impact, and is returned to the human food supply.
We’re building awareness by comparing it to more familiar circular economy ideas, like reusing furniture or clothing. We’re just doing it with food.
Q: Do you face resistance when you say your food is upcycled?
06:17
It’s changed a lot in the past five years. Back in 2016 when we started, people would say, “You want us to eat trash?” And we’d be like, no! That’s not what this is at all.
Now, people are more aware. The pandemic made folks rethink food waste at home. Climate change impacts are more visible in daily life. There's this universal agreement that food waste is a problem. And consumers like having a tangible way to make a difference, using their dollar to support upcycled food, which also happens to be delicious.
Q: Do your efforts support food security and access to nutrition for underserved communities?
07:27
Absolutely. The modern food system often strips out fiber and protein. We're trying to reclaim that and return it to the supply chain.
Fiber is one of the most lacking nutrients in the American diet, and it has big public health implications. Our ingredients are used in grain-free chips, tortillas, baby food, cookies, you name it.
We hope to do more to reach food-insecure communities. That’s currently more the domain of food rescue organizations, but as we scale and partner with larger food companies, we see real potential for upcycled food to help alleviate hunger.
Q: Tell us about the partnerships you’ve built. How do they support your mission?
09:05
Partnerships are the backbone of Renewal Mill. We work directly with producers, our first being a tofu company. Now we partner with soy milk and oat milk producers, and we’re expanding into cornmeal and juicing byproducts.
On the marketing side, we align with mission-driven brands that have large audiences. For example, we partnered with Miyoko’s Creamery, a vegan butter company. They had leftover butter, and we combined that with our upcycled flour to create cookies. It’s a great cross-promotion, sustainability and animal welfare brought together.
Q: What was your vision for Renewal Mill’s identity when you started, and how has that evolved?
11:19
We wanted to convey renewal, circularity, and hope. There’s so much bleakness in the climate space. We wanted to show that there’s a better way.
Our messaging has shifted too. While we lead with the sustainability story, we've learned that deliciousness sells first. If it tastes amazing, people will try it, and then they’ll care about the food waste story.
Q: What challenges have you faced in building the brand?
12:56
It’s still a challenge. We’re both an ingredients company and a consumer packaged goods company. The market isn't fully educated yet. We’re seeing growing interest, especially from companies wanting to make swaps for upcycled ingredients, but it's early days.
Supply chain consistency is also critical. That’s why we focus on byproduct streams that are expanding, like tofu and oat milk.
Q: How do you see the future of upcycled food evolving?
14:10
We envision upcycled food in every grocery aisle. There are already companies using yogurt whey, avocado pits, day-old bread, there's so much innovation.
Ultimately, we’d love to see food waste eliminated. We’re not there yet, but upcycled food is gaining global traction, especially in Europe, Asia, and South America.
Certifications like the Upcycled Certified label help consumers identify food waste-fighting products. And we’re working with multinationals on simple ingredient swaps that have huge impact.
Q: What lessons have you learned as a sustainability-focused entrepreneur?
16:07
It’s about collaboration. That’s why we helped found the Upcycled Food Association, so we could share knowledge and accelerate impact.
In just 18 months of launching the certification, certified products prevented nearly a billion pounds of food waste. That’s way more than we could do alone.
Also, it's critical to align with stakeholders’ ESG goals and learn how to present data in ways that resonate.
And most importantly, stay hopeful. The climate space can feel overwhelming. But entrepreneurs bring energy and solutions. We have to keep that spark alive.
Q: What major challenges have you faced in bringing your product to market?
18:59
Fundraising has been tough. We don't fit neatly in a single box. We’re an ingredient supplier, a CPG company, and we do private label.
It’s also challenging to introduce a novel ingredient. People don't know what it is or why they should care. We learned we had to show it, in a chocolate chip cookie, for example, so people could taste it and understand its potential.
Ingredient adoption can take 3–5 years. There’s a lot of education and testing involved. But we're getting better at shortening that timeline.
Q: What feedback have you received from customers?
21:21
It’s been incredibly positive. Ingredient buyers love the fiber and protein, and the story of sustainability it gives their brand.
Some use it to talk about food waste. Others, like one baby food company, use it to support early allergen introduction with soy, something we hadn’t anticipated, but it's exciting.
Consumers of our branded products often say they can't believe our mixes are vegan and gluten-free. They bring them to gatherings because they work for everyone, and they feel good about the impact.
Q: Have you incorporated customer feedback into product development?
23:11
Yes, definitely. We have an “insiders group” from our website who we send early products to for feedback.
We’re currently relaunching our ready-to-eat cookies and have surveyed customers on preferences and improvements. Feedback is a gift, it makes our products better.
Q: What advice would you give to other sustainability entrepreneurs aiming to build circular economy solutions?
24:01
Understand the problem from all angles. Most food manufacturers didn’t set out to create waste, it’s just how their systems were built.
Approach them with curiosity and empathy. Be ready to adapt your solution. A beginner's mindset is key, learn from their perspective and adjust accordingly.
Entrepreneurship is about flexibility. Especially when you're building relationships and navigating systems, you have to stay open and humble.
Q: Do you believe anyone can join the sustainability space, or is it only for those already in it?
25:50
Anyone can join. The more the merrier.
We’re facing the hottest year on record. We need all hands on deck. And right now, there’s more support and funding than ever for climate projects.
So if you have an idea, go for it. We need it.
26:34
Well hey there, we’ve reached the end of another Green New Perspective podcast episode.
Thank you for tuning into my conversation with Caroline from Renewal Mill. I hope you learned something about food waste and upcycled food.
If you enjoyed the episode, or just picked up a new insight, hit that subscribe button. That way you won’t miss any of our future conversations from the climate tech world.
And don’t be shy! Leave us a comment, share your favorite moment, or suggest a guest you’d like us to feature.
Until next time, keep those headphones on, keep those ideas coming, and keep being the awesome listeners you are.
Cheers!